Is Nancy Drew Still Sleuthing Today?

Beth Kanell, one of my fellow authors from the brand new e-book 25 Years in the Rearview Mirror, 52 Authors Look Back, and I are doing a blog exchange today, so after you read Beth’s post here you can read mine on her blog here!

If you enjoy magazine columns and Chicken Soup for the Soul books, then we’re sure to enjoy our collection of essays, designed to warm your heart, raise your spirits and compel you to examine your own life. Read about school days, quirky jobs, romance, raising a family, hard times, the writing journey, and find out what makes your favorite characters tick.

Get a full listing of authors, essay titles and retailers here: http://ning.it/OknwVR

Follow the 25 Years in the Rearview Mirror Blog and Radio Tour schedule here: http://ning.it/NZpHrP And don’t miss the chance to join the 25 Years in the Rearview Mirror Yahoo Group, a fun and inspirational group that discusses the past and will help you to stay on track for the future. Http://ning.it/O6vWdG

Is Nancy Drew Still Sleuthing Today?

Are you one of the many readers — like Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, former First Lady Laura Bush, and retired Congresswoman Pat Schroeder — who discovered Nancy Drew in childhood and enjoyed the uncomplicated successes of this teen sleuth? “She was smart and she didn’t have to hide it!” commented Schroeder in a New York Times interview.

Many mystery authors agree that the Nancy Drew stories marked them in some way. Even crime fiction leader Sara Paretsky, who didn’t identify as a child with the relatively privileged world of Nancy, came to see her as a symbol of independence and exuberant strength.

So, why is it so hard to find today’s Nancy Drews? Since the 1930 start of the original series, the Western world has welcomed smart, independent women, hasn’t it? But have you read anything lately that made you say, “Here is today’s titian-haired sleuth” — and then look for the next book in the series?

Part of the answer has to be the complications that we now expect in our fiction. Alan Bradley’s Flavia de Luce, for instance, is a dogged sleuth with a lot of intellect. But her fondness for poisons at age 11 is demonstrated to be antisocial and dangerous, if useful, and she knows that her family considers her too smart for her own good. (What woman hasn’t heard that line, even today?) Plus her investigations over subsequent books also reveal an underlying sorrow of her life. Underlying sorrow! Never would that appear in a Nancy Drew book. Independence, freedom of choice, a “roadster” to drive (without owing payments), a boyfriend who does just what she asks — Nancy Drew has the easy life and we follow along, at least when we’re kids, with a hunger and confidence in solutions and justice.

I love complicated books. I believe writers need to confront school bullying in fiction, admit that parents aren’t perfect, and challenge easy convictions that ignore DNA evidence.

But I also can’t ignore the lasting presence of Nancy Drew as an inspiration for people who are smart and committed and independent. Life is complicated; Nancy Drew is simpler. And we need her, even today.

[Beth Kanell is writing a Vermont teen sleuth series featuring Felicity “Lucky” Franklin. Will she succeed in crafting a worthy successor to Nancy Drew? Find out, chapter by chapter, at http://www.wattpad.com/3668250-all-that-glitters-chapter-1-all-that-glitters-by, and look over the author’s shoulder at bethkanell.blogspot.com.]

This entry was posted in Guest blog, Mysteries, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Is Nancy Drew Still Sleuthing Today?

  1. Beth Kanell says:

    Thanks, Karen — I love visiting at your blog, and I’m enjoying exploring your books, with their wonderfully diverse approaches!

  2. Stacy Juba says:

    I loved Nancy Drew growing up and I still love reading books about women sleuths. I’ve recently been reading the Nancy Drew Clue Crew books for kids – a fun way to introduce young readers to simple mysteries. Your series sounds terrific, Beth. Thanks to both you and Karen for participating in the blog tour.

  3. Barbara Ross says:

    Hi Beth!

    I recently read Girl Sleuth: Nancy Drew and the Women Who Created Her by Melanie Rehak. I totally recommend it–its an absolutely fascinating story.

    Books about girl adventurers who didn’t exist to “get the man” were rare to non-existent when Nancy first came on the scene. I decided her enduring fascination is that she’s as plucky and independent as Jo March, but without all the duty, sadness, obligation–and of course, no mother!

    Barb

  4. Jake says:

    Even young guys were exposed to Nancy Drew. Always have enjoyed any well written mystery. Find some of the current women sleuths better presented than their male counter parts. Going to read your All That Glitters as sounds like a real mystery for us all. Thank you.